misskris on "[Plugin: Chimpy Lite - MailChimp WordPress Plugin] 2nd form not sending email and going to wrong list"

Hi, I have 2 forms on my site, each one goes to a different mailchimp opt-in list, or at least it is supposed to. I have double opt-in checked, but when people use the 2nd form they are not getting a confirmation email and when looking in my mailchimp account they show up on the 1st list. Any idea why this could be happening?

https://wordpress.org/plugins/chimpy-lite/